Nature & Environment
GM Wheat Fails Field Test: Genetically Modified Crop Doesn't Repel Aphids
Catherine Griffin
First Posted: Jun 25, 2015 04:34 PM EDT
It turns out that genetically modified wheat may be falling a bit short. The GMO, which was designed to repel aphids, hasn't managed to do so in a field test.
Aphids cause major issues for wheat growers. The tiny insects feed on sap, and an infestation of aphids can reduce a harvest significantly; that's why researchers turned to genetic modification to see if that could potentially help matters.
So how would the wheat repel aphids? Scientists modified wheat to produce a natural pheromone which aphids release when under attack from predators. This "alarm" causes insects to flee to safety. It appears, though, that the field test wasn't a success.
"The disappointed thing was when we tested it in the field we didn't find any significant reduction [in aphids], said Toby Bruce, a chemical ecologist at Rothamsted, in an interview with Nature. "We didn't get the result that would have been useful in taking this forward. It was quite sad."
So why didn't it work? The researchers believe that it didn't work in nature because the aphids become used to the continuous release of the alarm pheromone. Over time, the aphids learn to ignore the pheromone and simply feed.
"I can imagine that the authors were misled because the application of the alarm pheromone 'worked' in laboratory experiments to repel aphids," said Jonathan Gershenzon at the Max Planck Institute for Chemical Biology, in an interview with The Guardian. "Like many workers before them they probably applied the pheromone in an unnatural way so that the dose was much higher than seen under more natural conditions."
It seems that the GM wheat didn't work this time. However, that doesn't mean that future studies aren't going forward.
Related Stories
GMO Fish: What Happens if They Escape into the Wild?
For more great science stories and general news, please visit our sister site, Headlines and Global News (HNGN).
See Now:
NASA's Juno Spacecraft's Rendezvous With Jupiter's Mammoth Cyclone
©2024 ScienceWorldReport.com All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission. The window to the world of science news.
More on SCIENCEwr
First Posted: Jun 25, 2015 04:34 PM EDT
It turns out that genetically modified wheat may be falling a bit short. The GMO, which was designed to repel aphids, hasn't managed to do so in a field test.
Aphids cause major issues for wheat growers. The tiny insects feed on sap, and an infestation of aphids can reduce a harvest significantly; that's why researchers turned to genetic modification to see if that could potentially help matters.
So how would the wheat repel aphids? Scientists modified wheat to produce a natural pheromone which aphids release when under attack from predators. This "alarm" causes insects to flee to safety. It appears, though, that the field test wasn't a success.
"The disappointed thing was when we tested it in the field we didn't find any significant reduction [in aphids], said Toby Bruce, a chemical ecologist at Rothamsted, in an interview with Nature. "We didn't get the result that would have been useful in taking this forward. It was quite sad."
So why didn't it work? The researchers believe that it didn't work in nature because the aphids become used to the continuous release of the alarm pheromone. Over time, the aphids learn to ignore the pheromone and simply feed.
"I can imagine that the authors were misled because the application of the alarm pheromone 'worked' in laboratory experiments to repel aphids," said Jonathan Gershenzon at the Max Planck Institute for Chemical Biology, in an interview with The Guardian. "Like many workers before them they probably applied the pheromone in an unnatural way so that the dose was much higher than seen under more natural conditions."
It seems that the GM wheat didn't work this time. However, that doesn't mean that future studies aren't going forward.
Related Stories
GMO Fish: What Happens if They Escape into the Wild?
For more great science stories and general news, please visit our sister site, Headlines and Global News (HNGN).
See Now: NASA's Juno Spacecraft's Rendezvous With Jupiter's Mammoth Cyclone